Peter Sutter, November 18, 2026

Iniya thanks everyone who hasn’t stopped believing in the impossible…
After years of political persecution, torture, and imprisonment – without ever having committed the slightest offense, solely because of their belonging to the Tamil minority – Dharini and Karthik (names changed) fled Sri Lanka to Romania in early 2018, hoping to find protection from persecution and secure permanent residence there. But by the end of 2024, after seven years of daily struggle to survive under the most precarious conditions and without any state support, all hope is destroyed: their asylum application is finally rejected by the Romanian authorities, and they face deportation back to Sri Lanka, which would mean political persecution, imprisonment, torture, and possibly even death again, since an arrest warrant issued just before their flight to Romania against both Dharini and Karthik is still valid. The fate of Iniya, who was born in Romania in June 2024, would also be highly uncertain if she would be sent back to Sri Lanka. Most likely, the family would be torn apart, and the child would end up in an orphanage at best, or fall victim to traffickers at worst. In their desperation, Dharini and Karthik turn to the UN High Commissioner in Geneva. They are advised to seek asylum in Switzerland, where it is assumed that the chance of a safe and dignified life in the future would be greater than in any other European country.
But the UN High Commissioner’s Office seems to have missed the increasing tightening of Swiss asylum policy since that golden era when Switzerland was actually still a haven for human rights. After a daring escape, during which they only narrowly avoided a police check at Bucharest’s main train station, Dharini, Karthik, and nine-month-old Iniya arrive in Switzerland, where they submit their asylum request on March 30, 2025. Finally, a roof over their heads and enough to eat, finally medical care for the ailing Iniya, which had been denied to them in Romania.
But exactly one month later comes the letter that destroys all hope once again: ‚The State Secretariat for Migration SEM has determined that Romania is responsible for your further procedure. Therefore, your asylum application will not be considered and your reasons for asylum will not be assessed.‘ Read it carefully: The application is not assessed, the asylum request is not considered. The rejection of the asylum application is justified by the SEM solely and exclusively with the so-called Dublin Agreement, according to which the country where asylum seekers first enter European soil – in this case Romania – is responsible for the further asylum procedure. Even though Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, Article 33 of the Geneva Refugee Convention, as well as the internationally established, Switzerland-signed non-refoulement principle, unequivocally state that no one may be deported to a country where they face danger to their life or physical integrity, the SEM does exactly that: Fully aware of this but keeping it quiet, that sending Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya back to Romania would automatically mean sending them back to Sri Lanka, and blindly relying on the Dublin Regulation, the SEM breaks all relevant European and international agreements. On top of that, even if this were a classic Dublin case, the SEM always has the right to a so-called ’self-admission,‘ meaning the chance to assess an asylum application from scratch, regardless of whether an application has already been submitted in another European country or not. Contrary to this fact, the SEM falsely keeps claiming over and over that it has no decision-making freedom and is legally obliged to send the family back to Romania – regardless of what happens to the family after returning to Romania. According to the SEM, Switzerland would ’not be responsible‘ for that.
The complaint now filed by the public defender against the SEM’s decision to the Federal Administrative Court is a complete farce: The Federal Administrative Court adopts the SEM’s ruling without question and thus becomes an accomplice in multiple violations of European agreements and international law, with unforeseeable, potentially deadly consequences for the refugee family involved. The confirmation of SEM’s decision not to proceed by the Federal Administrative Court on May 15, 2025, is final; those affected by the ruling have no further appeal options and no entitlement to additional legal support, because unlike all other court decisions made in Switzerland, decisions in the asylum sector cannot be taken to the Federal Court. Theoretically, the only option left is to take it to a European or international court, but then Santa Claus would have to come first and cover the horrendous costs of such a procedure.
And so it happens as it must. In August 2025, the first attempt at a forced deportation takes place, at five in the morning, with three police officers. Thanks to the violent physical resistance from Dharini and Karthik, the deportation attempt is ultimately called off. On September 4, a second attempt occurs, this time with nine police officers, again at five in the morning. But once more, due to violent resistance, the attempt has to be stopped, though it leads to such a total psychological breakdown for Karthik – still deeply suffering and traumatized from the severe torture he endured nine years earlier in Sri Lanka – that after returning to the asylum center, he tries to take his own life by stabbing shards of a broken bottle into his chest, but fortunately survives with serious injuries.
On November 15, 2025, the transfer deadline to Romania expires, which means that from that moment on, Switzerland will once again be responsible for the further asylum process of Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya. Dharini and Karthik feel hopeful again, thinking that there might still be a chance to get asylum in Switzerland. But what does the SEM do? Hard to believe, but true: it extends the transfer deadline by a whole year! With the following reasons: First, the family had „not cooperated“ or behaved „resistantly“ during the first two deportation attempts with the police officers. As if any SEM lawyer or not even the responsible Federal Councillor Beat Jans wouldn’t fiercely try to resist if they were dragged out of bed at five in the morning and sent to a country where they could be in potential danger. But the SEM pulls yet another reason out of its hat: During the asylum process, Dharini and Karthik were temporarily ‚off the grid,‘ meaning they had unlawfully left the asylum center and were supposedly trying to evade deportation. In reality, Dharini’s so-called ‚disappearance‘ was just a two-week stay in a psychiatric clinic – her lawyer had to submit the written confirmation of the clinic stay twice before it was accepted by the SEM. Karthik’s supposed ‚off the grid‘ time was just a four-day visit to a friend in Zurich, which isn’t illegal – the asylum center isn’t a prison – and Karthik’s only ‚offense‘ was failing to properly check out with the asylum center office.
The lawyer’s complaint against the completely arbitrary and utterly unfounded decision of the SEM to extend the surrender period by a year is, however, immediately rejected. Guess three times by whom: Of course, by the SEM itself! And this with no further chance of appeal. And so it all starts over again. Not a single evening, when they go to bed, Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya can be sure they won’t be woken up at five in the morning and forcibly taken away by the police, first to Romania, then to Sri Lanka into the death zone.
And indeed: On February 24, 2026, the third deportation attempt takes place, this time with 15 police officers, at three in the morning. Now any resistance is useless. First, Iniya is torn out of bed, then the parents. Karthik is led into a separate room and forced to strip naked and then hold a painful position for more than half an hour, with his legs being forcibly spread apart – this procedure defies any logical explanation and can only be interpreted as arbitrary harassment and humiliation of a defenseless victim of police violence. Deliberately, the harassment takes place in a room without video surveillance, so there is no evidence of the incident. Afterwards, the father and mother – both handcuffed like serious criminals – and the child are taken to Kloten airport in two separate vehicles, with Iniya sitting in the same vehicle as her mother but unable to see her due to a barrier – a deeply traumatic experience for the one-and-a-half-year-old child, who will still react with shaking and crying for weeks when losing eye contact with her parents. In Kloten, Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya are transferred to a special plane chartered for this purpose. It’s one of about 50 special flights organized each year by the SEM to forcibly deport „unruly“ refugees – on average twelve per day – out of Switzerland.
Arriving in Bucharest, the family has to wait for hours outdoors in freezing temperatures without any food, before being assigned to a completely overcrowded place that smells awful, with trash lying around and full of cockroaches. At least, thanks to little Iniya, they don’t end up in prison, otherwise the story would have ended right there and I would never have heard from Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya again. So, we stay in touch.
The very next day, the Romanian authorities start putting pressure on Dharini and Karthik to leave Romania for Sri Lanka as quickly as possible. Everything is back to square one. But what keeps coming to mind in moments like this? It’s that famous line by Bertolt Brecht: ‚When injustice becomes law, resistance becomes duty.‘ Luckily, there’s Western Union, so you can send money from one country to another easily and without bureaucracy. And luckily, there are no passport checks at the borders between the Schengen countries. And luckily, there are a few unmanned border crossings between Austria and Switzerland…
At the beginning of March 2026, Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya are back in Switzerland. Once again, it’s ground zero. And yet, it’s not the same as it used to be…
By now, Dharini is six months pregnant with a little brother for Iniya. Iniya already speaks a bit of Swiss German, in addition to Tamil and English. And Karthik’s emotional and physical wounds are slowly starting to heal, even though sometimes he still falls into a deep slump for a day or two.
Today, on November 18, 2026, the latest decision from the SEM has arrived: ‘Based on a summary review of the files, we request the Cantonal Migration Office to temporarily suspend the enforcement of the deportation as a precautionary measure (Art. 111b para. 3 Asylum Act).’
Today the angels in heaven threw a party. And they send a big, hearty thank you. To everyone who never gave up hope all this time and showed so much support for Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya, donated clothes, food, or a smaller or larger sum of money. To the 5,247 people who signed the online petition from Campax. To everyone who helped organize the rally on October 2, 2026, in Bern, especially Juso Bern. To the 216 people who attended this rally and then signed the petition over the following two weeks, which I then sent personally along with a letter from Dharini to Mr. Vincenzo Mascioli, the top boss of SEM. To my nephew, who is working on a documentary about the story of Dharini, Karthik, and Iniya, which will be released on social media early next year. To everyone who tirelessly sent personal letters to the SEM. To the journalist from Tages-Anzeiger and the editor-in-chief of the Liechtensteiner Sonntagszeitung, who each published a full-page article about this story. To the reporter from Bern’s local radio station «Rabe», who attended the rally on October 2 and then reported on it. To the lawyer who often wrote tirelessly late into the night. We don’t really know exactly what ultimately tipped the scales in a finally positive direction, maybe it was simply the sum of it all.
But alongside the laughing eye, there is also a crying eye. Because there are far too many other Dharinis, Karthiks and Iniyas whom no one cares about and whose stories never reach the public, far too many who lose their lives namelessly in the swamps between Poland and Belarus, at the bottom of the Mediterranean, or in the Libyan desert. As long as the top priority of European asylum policy, as stated so inhumanely in the latest EU Migration and Asylum Pact of June 12, 2026, is to protect borders rather than to protect people, there is still an endless amount of work to do.
Infinite work for the angels in heaven. But not just for them, also for us. Because the angels up in heaven especially need us humans down here on earth, since without our concern, without our compassion, without our actions, without our resistance, and without our courage, the angels will never, ever manage on their own.